Luckily for them, the film’s head of makeup spared a few details. Glossier describes the shade ($18, Glossier) as a “light, powdery pink,” which Noraz used to accentuate Dakota Johnson’s natural lip color on set. #9 Nude in Private ($37, YSL Beauty) is pretty damn close to the real thing. This lipstick above could be the same one shown in the wedding scene, but we’d like to think it’s a slightly deeper shade like YSL’s #61 Nu Impulsif ($37, YSL Beauty). But maybe we’ll never know. After all, mystery is “Fifty Shades’” entire allure.